What You Should Know Before Choosing a Loyalty Provider

by Joanna Reddy

Choosing a loyalty provider is one of the most important decisions a convenience retailer or fuel brand can make—yet many jump in without a full picture of what long-term success truly requires. 

Whether you’re launching your first program or replacing a legacy system, the right partner does more than deliver technology. They shape your ability to attract new customers, build lasting loyalty, drive incremental revenue, and adapt faster as your business grows. At PDI Technologies, we’ve worked with thousands of retailers over the past 40 years—and we’ve seen firsthand what works, what doesn’t, and what to look for before you commit to a partner. 

Here are five loyalty truths every retailer should understand. 

1. You’re not buying software—you’re choosing a partner 

You should think of loyalty as a long game. Too often, retailers approach it as a line item instead of a growth strategy. But a loyalty provider isn’t just a vendor—they should be your strategic ally. 

Look for a partner who understands your business model, helps you plan for launch and beyond, and sticks around to optimize the results with you. Their capabilities should include: 

  • Industry-specific experience
  • Personalized onboarding and training
  • Transparent insights and reporting
  • A collaborative mindset 

PDI doesn’t just implement programs—we build lasting relationships. Our strategic consulting team is engaged throughout your loyalty journey, helping you unlock full program value from day one. 

2. Integration isn’t optional—it’s essential 

Disconnected systems are one of the fastest ways to undermine a loyalty program’s success. Loyalty should touch every part of your operation—from the POS to mobile, back office, and CPG-funded promotions. 

When your systems work together, your loyalty program runs smoother, delivers better insights, and makes a bigger impact. 

PDI Loyalty is designed for true end-to-end integration, including: 

  • POS and fuel pump prompts
  • Mobile apps, payments, and ordering
  • Pricebook sync for real-time offer accuracy, including in-store marketing such as Electronic Shelf Labels
  • Offer orchestration with targeted marketing and vendor support 

3. Points alone won’t get you there 

It’s not enough to offer a punch card or points-for-purchases rewards. Today’s shoppers expect more personalized, immediate, and relevant rewards—and they’ll switch brands if they don’t get what they need. 

That’s why PDI helps retailers move beyond “earn-and-burn” programs, with tools like: 

  • Tiered loyalty structures and milestone rewards
  • Gamified experiences and regional offers
  • Insights and analytics to test and refine campaigns 

With PDI Experience Designer, even a small team can launch and manage advanced promotions using pre-built templates, segmentation, and automated campaigns. It’s loyalty management made simple yet powerful. 

4. You have to ask the questions that actually matter 

Choosing a provider shouldn’t be a guessing game. You need clear answers to questions like: 

  • Who owns the data—and how is it used?
  • How will your team support me after go-live?
  • Can your platform adapt to future needs like subscriptions or cross-channel rewards? 

But don’t stop there. In our experience, some of the most important loyalty questions are specific to the c-store environment: 

  • Can your solution handle age-restricted promotions and fuel rewards?
  • How do you support franchise models or multi-brand operations?
  • Can you help us access and activate CPG offers to reduce costs? 

PDI can answer “yes” to all of the above—and we have the results to prove it. 

5. The best programs are also the best-executed 

Even the most advanced loyalty platform won’t produce solid results without strong execution in the store. That’s why we place so much emphasis on training, incentives, and ongoing engagement. 

Here are five actions that consistently improve ROI: 

  1. Ensure company alignment, incorporating loyalty program KPIs into each department’s goals
  2. Train associates to promote the program during every customer interaction
  3. Monitor by location, recognizing and rewarding performance and improvement  
  4. Incorporate employee benefits into your loyalty program to reinforce adoption 
  5. Continually refine your program based on performance—not just assumptions 

Final thought: loyalty is a business strategy, not a software purchase 

When done right, loyalty can become your most powerful growth lever—driving revenue, increasing customer lifetime value, and differentiating your brand. 

At PDI Technologies, we’ve helped retailers transform loyalty from a marketing tactic to a competitive advantage. We don’t just sell software—we help you build a loyalty strategy that works for your business, your stores, and your customers. 

Ready to transform your loyalty program?

Let’s Talk

Like to hear more about PDI Loyalty solutions?

Be sure to join us at Connections Live 2025 in Denver, CO from August 24-27. This is your opportunity to hear PDI leaders discuss the latest solutions and future roadmaps for payments and loyalty.
Register Now  

Want more loyalty content from PDI?

Check out C-Store Loyalty Insider for the latest in convenience loyalty—at PDI and across the industry.