Turn Holiday Travelers Into Loyal Customers: Your Guide to Winning Repeat Visits

One fill-up, one coffee, and they’re back on the road. For many holiday travelers, it’s their first visit to your store. Unless you give them a reason to return, it could be their last.

The holiday crowd is driving

23% of U.S. adults plan a holiday road trip to see family or friends. Only 11% plan to fly.¹ More of your holiday traffic arrives by car.

That’s a wave of first-timers at your pumps, and a short window to win them.

They’re choosy about where they stop

38% of holiday shoppers call themselves value seekers.²  That mindset rides along on the road trip.

The first station off the exit isn’t the automatic pick anymore. The one with rewards drivers can see and use right away is.

Someone passing through won’t come back for a punch card. Give them a reason to join before their tank is full.

Get in vacation mode with them. Instead of a one-off discount, plan a week-long themed “earn it, redeem it” campaign that rewards travelers for stopping in on the way out and again on the way home. Lean into the joy of the season with festive creative, playful mechanics, and rewards that feel like a treat rather than a transaction. The goal isn’t just another visit. It’s making your store part of the trip.

Three ways to capture a road-tripper:

  • Make joining frictionless. A QR code or text-to-join prompt on the dispenser. That’s it.
  • Reward them instantly. Offer a deal at the pump, where they already are. 
  • Bring them inside. Pair the pump-side welcome with an in-store offer. A quick stop often becomes a multi-item basket.
  • Measure what stuck. In January, check how many holiday sign-ups came back. Track them with the same loyalty program KPIs you use year-round.

Then put the opt-in to work. Time a return-trip offer to the drive home, especially the Sunday after Thanksgiving and Christmas.  

The takeaway

Holiday traffic will look a lot like last year. The traveler won’t. More of them are driving, and they’re pickier about where they stop. Make joining your program the easiest decision at the pump and give every first-timer a reason to come back.

PDI logo favicon

Ready to make sure your rewards program is the gift that keeps on giving?

¹ YouGov survey of 2,445 U.S. adults for The Points Guy, fielded Sept. 18–22, 2026, as reported in “Holiday travel survey,” Oct. 5, 2026.

² Deloitte, 2026 Holiday Retail Survey, as reported by HomePage News, Oct. 16, 2026.