The Power of Not Knowing: Why Being New Can Be Your Edge

At the Women in Convenience lunch at Connections Live 2026, Annie Gauthier of St. Romain Oil Company and Jessica Hendrickson of Altria joined moderator Linnea Geiss of PDI Technologies for a candid conversation about the moments that shaped them as leaders, from imposter syndrome to burnout.

The stories were personal, but the messages behind them apply to any career. Every promotion, new team, or unsolved problem can put even the most experienced professional back in the rookie seat.

The rookie advantage, at any stage

The panel spoke openly about imposter syndrome, and one distinction stood out: you can sound like you know what you’re doing while still feeling like you don’t. Most people treat that gap as something to hide. The panel suggested leaning into it instead, with what was described as a ‘rookie advantage’: the ability to ask questions openly and without fear.

Those questions help more than the person asking. A fresh set of eyes can spot an outdated or confusing process, or an assumption no one has challenged in years. People who have been in a role for a long time often stop seeing those things, simply because they’ve learned to work around them.

The good news is that the rookie advantage isn’t tied to tenure. It’s a mindset anyone can adopt. Experienced professionals can approach a new project, a new customer, or a new technology like AI with the same curiosity they had in their first week. Asking “Why do we do it this way?” isn’t a sign you don’t belong. It’s often a question that can move a team forward.

Put it into practice:

  • Keep a running list of questions whenever you start something new and ask them before they start to feel too obvious to bring up.
  • Pick one process you rely on and ask why it works the way it does.
  • Pair each question with your observations, so curiosity comes across as a contribution.

Speak up when it counts

Another lesson came from an early-career experience in rooms full of executives. People shared ideas but rarely pushed back on each other. The lesson that came out of it still applies today: there’s a reason you’re in the seat, so make your voice heard.

The point wasn’t to disagree for the sake of it. Healthy debate is what makes a team better. A room where no one challenges an idea is a room where weak ideas go unchecked and strong ones never get sharpened.

For anyone, at any level, this is a reminder that silence has a cost. If you’re in the room, your perspective has value. Asking the harder question or naming what others are quietly thinking may feel uncomfortable at first, but over time it’s how you build credibility and earn trust.

Put it into practice:

  • Walk into meetings with one question or concern already in mind, so speaking up doesn’t depend on the moment.
  • Frame pushback around the shared goal. “What would it take for this to work?” can encourage a constructive conversation.
  • If the discussion moves too fast, don’t be afraid to follow up afterward.

Knowing when to look up

The panel also talked candidly about burnout and how demanding seasons of work and life can quietly pull someone away from their team.

They emphasized building real boundaries and suggested designing an “ideal week” (a concept from author Michael Hyatt). Focus on a rhythm that fits your life, rather than a perfect schedule.

This one applies to anyone who has ever said, “I’ll slow down after this project.” New challenges tend to pull you in, and it’s easy to drift off course without noticing. Stepping back to check in with yourself is part of being an effective leader. Self-care doesn’t mean giving less to everything else you’re responsible for.

Put it into practice:

  • Sketch your ideal week, including time for rest and the people who matter, then compare it to your actual calendar.
  • Put a recurring check-in with yourself on the calendar, especially during busy seasons.
  • Watch for early signs you’re pulling away, like skipped one-on-ones or shorter conversations with your team.

Participate, prepare, prioritize

The panel closed with simple advice anyone can use to grow their career:

  1. Participate.Don’t be passive. Share your perspective and challenge ideas constructively.
  2. Prepare.You don’t need to have every answer, but doing the work ahead of time gives you the footing to contribute with confidence.
  3. Prioritize.Be clear about what matters most, at work and outside of it, and protect it.

And underneath all three: you don’t get what you don’t ask for. That goes for questions, opportunities, support, and time.

The takeaway for every career

Every new challenge comes with a learning curve, whether it’s a first job, a promotion, a new team, or a problem no one has solved before. Experience doesn’t remove that curve. It only changes how you approach it.

So, the next time you’re in unfamiliar territory, ask the open question. Say what you see. Check in with yourself. And ask for what you need. Not having all the answers isn’t something to fix before you’re allowed to contribute. It’s often where the best questions, the boldest ideas, and the strongest leadership begin.

Start Making Your Plans Now

Connections Live 2027
August 29 – September 1, 2027
Gaylord Rockies Resort
Denver, Colorado

Sign up now to get the latest news, announcements, and exclusive content!