Why CPG Teams Should Stop Estimating the Independent Channel

For category managers and shopper insights teams, the challenge is straightforward: How do you grow your category in independent convenience when you do not have a complete view of the market? Six in ten convenience stores in the U.S. are independently operated – approximately 90,000 stores across the industry’s long tail. That is a major opportunity, but only if you can see where your brand is winning, where the category is growing, and where the gaps are. 

Most brands are not fully capitalizing on that opportunity because their view of independent stores is based on projections from sampled data, often provided with varying degrees of confidence. Without store-level visibility, category teams can spend too much time estimating the market and not enough time acting on it. 

Confidence comes from a strategy built on actual transaction data from independent stores rather than a projected estimate. When actual data says that a certain category sells in thousands of stores, that’s a count you can dig into and work with.  

PDI offers a distinctive perspective on this channel by connecting actual independent-store transaction data with shopper and basket insights. That gives category teams a clearer way to identify high-value opportunities and build a stronger story for independent retailers.  

This is the core challenge the PDI Client Insights & Analytics team addresses daily, and it’s something we covered in-depth in a recent on-demand webinar with the Category Management Association (CMA): Turning Independent Convenience Data into Actionable Category Strategies. Whether you work in CPG sales, category management, trade marketing, shopper insights, or space planning, you’ll come away with strategies to activate in an independent convenience market that is ripe for more brands to seize.  

So how do you move from lagging to leading in this channel? A few things stand out.  

First, you need a complete view into what’s really happening now for your brand in independent convenience, including:  

1. Where your brand sells today: Every independent store that rang up your brand in the trailing 13 weeks 

2. Where the entire category sells: The full addressable universe 

3. The gap: Every store selling the category but not your brand, and the geographic shape those gaps form 

4. The opportunity: Where the highest value, yet untapped, independent stores are concentrated 

The shopper story and the brand lift that resonates with retailers 

With that initial transaction data, you now know which stores to target, and you can really begin to leverage the deep shopper data inside those stores.  

Numerous opportunities stand out for brands, including: 

• Approximately 5% of shoppers drive roughly half the convenience spend: Because every basket ties to a store, you can see which of your gap stores those heavy-trip shoppers are already visiting. 

• Basket affinity data reveals what already travels with your brand: You can identify cross-merchandising partners from real transactions to pair with your brand. 

• What value does your brand bring to the overall basket: The example in the webinar shows a $1.25 lift in average basket value vs. the next-largest brand in the category—tangible data that gives retailers a reason to carry your brand. 

Promotions that measure what actually happened

The final section of the webinar tracks something every category manager has seen: the promotion that reported 25% growth but quietly didn’t perform that well. You’ll explore how to design offers based on what shoppers truly do in-store, and how to measure lift effectively. The result isn’t just a “headline” number; it’s one you can defend when someone asks what the offer was actually worth.  

The big takeaway from the webinar? The gap was always there. Now it has addresses. 

Watch the webinar 

Get the inside scoop from PDI experts in the on-demand webinar Turning Independent Convenience Data into Actionable Category Strategies as they share insights from the convenience retail market.

Pre-register for PDI Connections Live 2027

Ready to expand your skills and industry expertise? You can now pre-register for Connections Live 2027 in Denver, Colorado. Don’t miss out on the industry’s premier training and networking event!